Veteran journalist Sohail Waraich, known for his insightful political analysis and balanced reporting, is facing intense criticism over his latest column. The piece, published on August 16, 2025, recounted a brief encounter with Field Marshal Asim Munir in Brussels and included the statement that “political reconciliation is possible only if there is a sincere apology.”
Although Waraich never named Imran Khan or the May 9 case, political commentators and social media users interpreted this as a demand from the Army Chief for Khan to apologize over the 2023 May 9 riots. Within days, the comment snowballed into a national debate, prompting the DG ISPR to issue a formal clarification.
What Sohail Waraich Wrote
In his column, “Pehli Mulaqat”, Waraich described meeting Field Marshal Asim Munir during a Brussels stopover. He shared the Army Chief’s general remarks about reconciliation and sincerity but did not explicitly link them to any individual or political event.
The column’s reflective tone was meant to provide insight, not break news. However, one line about a “sincere apology” was widely interpreted as a direct message for Imran Khan, intensifying Pakistan’s already polarized political climate.
DG ISPR Clarification
On August 21, 2025, DG ISPR Lt Gen Ahmed Sharif held a press briefing, firmly stating:
- The meeting in Brussels was not an interview but a casual interaction.
- Field Marshal Asim Munir did not demand an apology over May 9.
- Neither PTI nor the May 9 events were discussed.
This clarification directly contradicted the popular narrative that had spread online, calming speculation but also raising questions about media responsibility.
Waraich’s Response
Facing a wave of online trolling, Sohail Waraich clarified that his column was misinterpreted. He stressed that he had not written Imran Khan’s name, mentioned May 9, or suggested any specific apology demand. His intent was to reflect on broader themes of political reconciliation, not deliver an official message on behalf of the military.
Why the Story Exploded: Media and Perception
The uproar highlights a deeper issue in Pakistan’s media landscape:
- Ambiguous Wording: Without clear attribution, readers filled in the blanks.
- Social Media Amplification: Politically charged narratives spread faster than corrections.
- Format Confusion: A reflective column was treated like an official statement, fueling controversy.
- Public Distrust: In a highly polarized environment, even seasoned journalists face attacks for perceived bias.
Lessons for Journalists: Staying Neutral and Honest
This episode is a wake-up call for journalists, editors, and commentators:
- Quote Precisely: Use exact words; avoid assumptions.
- Clarify Context: If a person or case isn’t named, state that explicitly.
- Separate Opinion and Reporting: Clearly label opinion pieces and news stories.
- Fact-Check Sensitive Remarks: Always seek confirmation from official sources before publishing.
- Be Transparent: Update and correct content swiftly when new information comes in.
- Avoid Becoming a Spokesperson: Journalists should report, not deliver messages for powerful institutions.
The Bigger Picture: Journalism Under Scrutiny
Sohail Waraich’s reputation as a balanced voice in Pakistan’s media is being tested. However, this controversy reflects a broader challenge: journalists are operating in an environment where every word is politicized. In such times, accuracy and neutrality are not just virtues—they are survival tools.
For readers, this story is also a reminder: not everything you see online is a fact. Interpretations, tweets, and headlines can distort the original intent of a piece, turning nuance into controversy.
Conclusion: A Call for Clarity in Media
The “apology” controversy around Sohail Waraich isn’t simply about one journalist; it’s about the responsibility of the press in a volatile political climate. Transparency, honesty, and careful wording are critical. For Pakistan’s journalists, this moment is a case study in why clarity is power—and why neutrality remains the profession’s most valuable currency.
👍